At the MLK Memorial |
Sunday, July 8, 2012
NYC and DC
Meeting with Maria and John Chrin |
These past few days have been jam packed with activities! Seeing New York City through the eyes of those who have never seen it before was an experience I really cherished; the girls were so happy, excited and overwhelmed and it brought me great joy to see them this way. Meeting with Maria and John Chrin was an awesome experience because we got to meet one of the people that make programs like ours possible. I am so grateful to her for providing opportunities like this to Lehigh students and she is an amazing and inspiring person.
The most challenging and controversial visit in NYC was when we met with Daisy Khan. My family and community were deeply affected by the events of 9/11 and it is still a sore subject for me to talk about. I remember sitting in my third grade class when we got the news and being so worried when my mom called to come and get me--I thought my dad was dead because his precinct was very close to the World Trade Center. Thankfully he did not go into work that day, but he did take part in much of the cleanup and even took part in the cataloging of many people's remains whom we knew personally or through friends. It was a very scary and sad time for America and especially New York. Going to the memorial was very hard for me because it was the first time I had been able and brave enough to go all the way in. I had not been that close since before the buildings fell. I was glad we went though because it was a very peaceful and cathartic experience for me after our speech with the brilliant, Daisy Khan.
Listening to Daisy Khan |
Dinner in Little Italy |
When I
had first heard about what Daisy Khan and her husband were planning, I
was really hurt. How could someone be so insensitive? Why would they put
their center so close to where the attacks took place? After listening
carefully to everything Daisy had to say, I was surprised to feel my
opinion shift. I didn't understand what she was planning to do and the
talks that she wanted to initiate, and after hearing that it was a
inter-religious dialogue center, I felt like an idiot. I had taken what
the news stations were saying as truth when in fact, they were
completely exaggerated. While I still think the location of the
mosque/community center is not the best idea, I agree that 9/11 needs to
be talked about. Daisy was right; we never healed. I also really liked
that she explained that that attack was not only on the WTC but on the
Muslim religion itself. I hope that in the near future, more Americans
will understand that the Muslim fundamentalists that carry out terrorist
acts are not the majority of their population. I hope that they
understand that terrorism is a threat to all Americans-not just the
white ones. It really, really, really, bothers me when these potentially
intelligent Americans let their prejudices and ignorance overcome their
capacity to love and cherish one another for the people we are and the
beliefs we have.
Once we had finally arrived in DC, it was great to see all of the landmarks and to see it once again with fresh eyes. Our Indonesian partners have fantastic questions, often about things I would normally take for granted or not even think of. I am really proud of the friendships we are forming and the dialogues we are having. I think this program has definitely come a long way. After reflecting on it today at American University, I can honestly say that this experience has changed the way I look at America. I have always been critical of America, but being in a different country and in a place so different from home only makes me appreciate the good things more. We are so lucky to have the freedoms that we do and to be able to express ourselves and our religion and that is one thing I no longer take for granted. I am so happy I decided to participate in this program and that I was presented such a wonderful and fulfilling opportunity. Until tomorrow! Ciao!!
--Shannon Cassidy, Lehigh University
Meeting two inspiring women in NYC
--Cindhi Cintokowati, Gadjah Mada University
Meeting with Daisy Khan |
Terrorism is the common enemy of American, American-Moslem, and Moslem
--Anggita Paramesti, Gadjah Mada University
Days 27, 28 and 29
Meeting with Rabbi Goren |
The past two days have been full of fun and lots of religious and political conversation. On Wednesday morning, we had a lecture from Professor Matthews on Individualism and Community in American Political Thought, which I believe further clarified the interactions between the students from both countries in public transportation and a host of other things. As we discussed with the very excellent Dr. Lule tonight, it is not common in American culture to sit directly next to someone on a bus or a train or even in a classroom. Americans like their space and alone time, which contrasts to the aspect of Indonesian culture that emphasizes group activity and bonding. It is just two different traditions embedded into the cultures and I'm really glad that, among other things was clarified. I would hate to offend them over something that I didn't even realize and that was one of the things I wish we knew to explain to the Indonesians when we arrived rather than finding out the hard way.
Another thing that was interesting was that the Indonesians loved the food at Rathbone because they could see it before taking it and they could better determine if they would enjoy it. The Lehigh students were less enthusiastic about it, but glad that the others enjoyed it so much. it was also great to have a discussion on Judaism yesterday because it was something that we, as a group, have not really studied in depth; it was not only educational to the exchange students, but eye opening to me as well because I would not have a reason to study it otherwise.
My FAVORITE day was today when we learned all about Buddhism! I found Professor Lloyd's lecture to be absolutely fascinating. There is so much to the religion that I really agree with and I wish that more people behaved like the ideal Buddhist. The Tibetan Buddhist Learning Center is something I definitely want to return to. I think that meditation and reflection are so important to a person's well being. Maybe during four o'clocks week I'll head over to meditate. Ta Ta for now! NYC HERE I COME!
--Shannon Cassidy, Lehigh University
Entering the Tibetan Buddhist Learning Center |
The
past two days have been filled with some really interesting discussions
about religion and religious pluralism. This Thursday, we had a lecture
on the basic concepts of Buddhism with Dr. Lloyd Steffen. Learning
about Buddhism and the importance to uphold yourself to be the best
person you can be right now was a really interesting idea that I had
always wanted to apply in my life but this idea seems to be very
different from what I had learned as a child. Growing up in a Catholic
family, I was raised to value good deeds by either helping out at church
events, doing some community service at orphanages, or simply helping
out your neighbors. Although helping others brings forward positivity to
others and yourself, the thought to always help others and to be a good
person was always followed by fear
about your afterlife—will I go to heaven or will I go to hell? Learning
about Buddhism was really refreshing. Later that day, we visited the
Tibetan Buddhist Learning Center where we met Diana. Diana is a
character! I very much enjoyed our visit at the Tibetan Buddhist
Learning Center because she was able to explain Buddhism in a very
simple manner. I definitely plan on attending the Buddhist study and tea
time sessions held every Sunday in the future.
After our visiting Diana, we had a visitor—Professor Jack Lule! I really appreciate our conversation with Professor Lule because not only did he learn about the daily activities that we took part in during the program thus far, we were also able to share the ups and downs of the program. I think that this conversation was a really important one to have because I believe that everyone was thinking about how intense this program is, mentally, physically, and spiritually, but it was not until Professor Lule said, “If this program was easy, we wouldn’t do it!” that it has occurred to everyone, or at least, me, that “Yes, this program is intense but that’s how it should be! I am learning!”. As intense as this program is, I am loving it! Although this program is focused religious pluralism and democracy, the activities and the entire structure of this program has challenged so many more aspects of my life. Not only are the lectures and the visits to various religious and political institutions important in learning the history and how people function in a society, but also living with our Indonesian and American friends and learning about them as individuals has also presented many opportunities to exchange ideas and to reflect on my own culture and identity. There are only five days of this program left and so many thoughts are firing in my head about everything! This program has truly changed me as a person, I just do not know exactly how yet.
--Theresa Mejia, Lehigh University
Wednesday, June 27, 2012
Day 26
Philadelphia |
The most beautiful thing about this trip for me is learning about my own nation through the eyes of others. Today we visited the Convention Center and the Jewish History Museum in Philadelphia--two very integral places of history that I have never experienced. On the way home from Philadelphia, our car discussions were filled with the nuances of American politics and how they compare with Indonesian policies. The questions went both ways, and I ended up thinking about the American political system in terms of the international perspective.
When first starting this journey, I was certain that the Indonesian portion would be far superior to anything the boring United States could offer. However, I am learning just as much from the activities we are doing here as from the Indonesian activities, which is absolutely amazing--I am do lucky to have the opportunity to experience these things with our Indonesian counterparts.
--Ellie Craig, Lehigh University
Chinatown |
I think that one of the more surprising things about the American portion of the trip are the cultural differences that were not necessarily so apparent when we were Indonesia. A lot of my experience in Indonesia lead me to believe that the two cultures were a lot more alike than I had assumed before I left. There were still rappers, there were class differences, and there were still regular young adults going to college and getting an education like we are, only on the other side of the world.
Once we were situated in America, I came to discern that there were intricacies to this difference in culture and understanding that I had not seen before. I would often hear participants asking if it was ok to say something or ask something that I had previously regarded as fine and socially acceptable, and then realize that it did not come as common sense to them because of a culture gap. It was a pleasant personal refresher on American etiquette. I also began to think about all the things I may have done or said while I was in Indonesia that may have been offensive or rude without even realizing it.
There are certain things about American culture that make it acceptable for many of us to feel very open and free with what we discuss and ask about, and things I did not even think about being remotely offensive (and it probably was, sorry). I feel bad about it. In the same breath, there are things that I notice about our group's experience here in America that I am offended by, but it has only made me realize exactly how different it is to be raised as an American versus being raised as an Indonesian.
Often when our cultures clash, it becomes awkward, and painfully quiet. I think it is important for us to talk about the awkward and offensive things as a group because if it keeps happening and we don't discuss it openly, then we aren't learning very much about each other. I value the friendships that are forming between everyone very much and I think through open discussion and bonding that we will become even closer. I look forward to tomorrow's discussions.
--Shannon Cassidy, Lehigh University
Learning about handmade Colonial every day things |
Today’s visit to the Constitution Center in Philadelphia was the ideal follow up to Professor Matthew’s lecture on the ratification of the Constitution in 1787. When establishing a federal system, James Madison’s ultimate goal was to prevent rapid change. Federalist 10 reveals Madison’s fear of the majority. How do you prevent the inevitable passion that will overcome a group of individuals who realize they all share the same goal? How do you maintain factions so that they don’t violate the rights of citizens?
One comment that stood out to me during this discussion was that James Madison didn’t rely on the goodwill of people to shape his thought-process; he merely built the American Political System around how he expected men and women to behave in their natural state. For example, knowing all men are power hungry, his first step was to extend the commercial republic so that it allowed them to make as much money as they wanted. Next, Madison was concerned with the unpredictable behavior of religious groups, so he demanded the separation of Church and State. This way, American citizens were able to create as many religious groups as they wanted as long as they didn’t permeate the political arena. “The more the merrier” because a more pluralistic society encourages less cohesion and minimizes the likelihood of a majority forming. With this in mind, how do you think Madison would advise the United States government to deal with the abortion issue? By dividing the power between three branches of government and creating a system of checks and balances to neutralize any concentration of power, it is clear that above all Madison wanted stability. So, rather than let the national government “pick a side,” he would turn it into a state issue.
While some states opt to legalize abortion, others will prohibit it. Despite the multiplicity of responses, there will still be stability within the U.S. government. Advancements like abortion, DNA, pharmaceutical companies, and health insurance represent modern day issues that the framers could not have prepared for. If we relied solely on the thinking of the framers and a strict interpretation of the Constitution, then African-Americans would still only be considered three-fifths of a person. An ongoing debate that began with the federalists and anti-federalists is centered on how this document should be interpreted. In my opinion, the Constitution should be treated as a skeletal framework, not a code of laws.
When reading the Constitution and applying it to contemporary issues, it all comes down to whether or not the decision upholds the principles of the democratic government and secures individual liberty. Every generation debates over how the Constitution should evolve and adapt to the controversial issues of that time. These conflicts are exactly what Madison hoped for when designing the federalist system. He wanted factions to compete with each other. President Obama’s inability to pass any legislation shows Madison succeeded in his goal to ensure incrementalism within the U.S. government. After two hundred years, the system is still saying no.
--Angela Farren, Lehigh University
Day 25
Showing the kids where in the world Indonesia is |
Today was just awesome! We started off with a lecture from Dr. Rick Matthews about Early American Political History. We discussed the Federalists Papers, more specifically The Federalist #10 by James Madison. This discussion was really interesting because it gives both the American and Indonesian students the view of the American system and how its history sheds light on how it functions today.
Learning about Indonesian dance |
Soon after this lecture was our visit to the Bethlehem Boys and Girls Club. The student participants of USIPP put together a pamphlet full of information about Indonesia and the things that we did and learned while we were in Indonesia. We handed out these packets so that the kids would be able to go along with our presentation. We were able to share things that we have learned, from Indonesian greetings, traditional batik clothes, petting Komodo dragons, meeting the Jogja Hip Hop Foundation, visiting the Merapi Volcano, and traditional Indonesian foods. The kids were so responsive, enthusiastic, and curious about the culture that it made this part of the program my favorite.
This visit to the Boys and Girls Club reminded me just how awesome kids are, because I feel that I can rethink and un-think things about the world when they ask me questions that I have never even thought about before! The kids are just so fun to be with. I loved this program and I hope this stays on future USIPP schedules.
--Theresa Mejia, Lehigh University
Dancing |
The federalist paper lecture was pretty serious, the rest of it was fun!
--Anggita Paramesti, Gadjah Mada University
Anggita, with bunny ears at Boys & Girls Club |
Making dinner together |
Making some American apple pie |
Sunday, June 24, 2012
Day 24
Picnic at Mama Nyby's |
Day 23
After stopping for some pretzels in Amish Country |
Today, when entering the bathroom at the Amish household, I found myself searching every wall for the light until I remembered where I was. Then I couldn’t help but think that our dependency on electricity is an understatement. Rather, for some, computers, cell phones, and televisions have become a means of survival. Technology has become a resource as vital as food and water for the average human being. Americans are not the only addicts. Recent statistics revealed that Indonesia is the number one user of Facebook and twitter. Prior to leaving for Indonesia, my boss told me he was conflicted with whether to bring his iPad, kindle, or laptop. That’s when you really have a problem. Seeing how the majority of the population is a slave to technology, you can’t help but admire the Amish for resisting progression and wanting to hold on to the traditions of their forefathers.
The beauty of their life is its simplicity. Their food is not drowning in a pool of chemicals, their kids’ bedrooms don’t look like arcades, and finally they have no problem seeing the stars at night. At the same time, as we discussed on the bus ride home, most Amish would not take advantage of an airplane, meaning they would never have the opportunity to explore the world. I never understand why Americans, Amish individuals and the average citizens alike, have no desire to see what’s beyond the walls of this nation. Every country is the product of a unique historical background and home to a distinctive group of people who value traditions and customs that can be found nowhere else. Why limit yourself to one area if so much more is out there? They may be able to Google a country like Indonesia, but it will never compare to physically experiencing their culture, tasting their food, hearing their language, and seeing the remarkable differences between both worlds. At the same time, the Amish do know how to cook. So, I can understand why that has grounded them for this long.
--Angela Farren, Lehigh University
Razwan Butt, introducing us to the Islamic Center of the Lehigh Valley |
Yesterday
was a pretty cool day all around. We started off by giving the
Indonesian girls a tour of Lehigh, and I couldn't have asked for better
weather to do so. While living day-to-day life at Lehigh, it is easy to
forget how beautiful our buildings and campus are. Afterwards, we went
to the Muslim Association of the Lehigh Valley, where a very special man
told us about what it means for him to be a Muslim in America. All to
often we hear of hate crimes and discrimination, which certainly still
exist in many parts of our country and the world; however, it was
heart-warming to hear how he has found a safe haven within the Lehigh
Valley. It was inspiring for me to hear about how much the Association
has integrated into daily society, for example by providing women's
shelters with fresh produce and meat and
by helping out a local school district to make their policies more
friendly to a variety of different religions.
We followed this up with a VERY different example of American religious tradition: Amish country in Lancaster, PA. Though I have been before, it was exciting to experience their world with a group of people who most likely have never seen anything like the Amish. The ride down to Lancaster and the Amish farms themselves were absolutely breathtaking, as are many PA landscapes. Even better, however, was the food. Everything from the homemade chips to the soft pretzels (to die for) to the delicious home cooked meal we had with a family, their food is simple and comforting. It was interesting to learn about what is appropriate and not in terms of modern comforts for the Amish, which both Americans and Indonesians had many questions about. Jane, our tour guide, explained that like so many other religions and groups around the world, the Amish sometimes don't even know why certain modern amenities are unacceptable.
Probably the coolest part for me was after Gita gave the little girl who helped serve us dinner the gift of a paper fan from Indonesia-perhaps a country she had never even heard of, let alone knew where it is. Stacy was there to witness the encounter, and spoke about how remarkable it probably was for the Amish women to see women in hijab, and how they were most likely itching to question them, but didn't want to seem impolite. In a situation where American and Indonesian students alike were learning much about the Amish community, it didn't even occur to me that the Amish community might have a few questions for us too--talk about some pretty cool dialogue.
--Ellie McGuire, Lehigh University
Earlier on that day, we also went to the Islamic Center of the Muslim Association of the Lehigh Valley. I love the discussion with Rizwan Butt. He made me understand more about my religion. He came from Bahrain and just like most of the Moslem who came from a country with the majority of Moslem; he took his religion for granted, just as me too. Then he went to United States and decided to learn about Islam from the very basic, releasing all cultural attachment and he found that Islam is a very beautiful.
That morning one of our interesting discussions was about Islam and women. Woman's status in Islam is one of the most controversial and serious issues of our time, not only among Muslim women and those who represent them in the area of women's rights in the Islamic world, but also among fundamentalist Muslims. Rizwan clarified to us about this thing. He explained that in Islam men and women are biologically different from each other and that’s why each has their respective roles. Not that it means men and women are not equal in Islam. He explained that from Aisha to Umm Waraqa, women in early Islam held numerous prominent positions as transmitters of hadith to spiritual, legal, and interpretive authorities. The rights granted to women in the Qur'an and by the prophet Muhammad were a vast improvement in comparison to the situation of women in Arabia prior to the advent of Islam. But after the Prophet's death, the condition of women in Islam began to decline and reverts back to pre-Islamic norms. “That’s why we need to understand Islam from different perspectives, not just taken it for granted”, he said. I agree.
The Amish: Another Portrait of America
In our first day of adventure in Pennsylvania, the committee brought us to visit the Amish Country. I should say that this is the most interesting Bethlehem’s part for me. If you imagining that all Americans live in the sophisticated world full of IPad, IPod, Macbook, and so on, well, I should say you’re not wrong. But not all Americans live like that. This Amish Country showed another dimension of Americans. Pennsylvania Amish Country is a picturesque landscape that must be witnessed in person to be fully appreciated. Rolling hills with lush grasses and crops, farms with windmills dotting the horizon and horse and buggies sharing the road remind you that things are simpler there in Lancaster County.
The story of the Pennsylvania Amish community dates back to the 16th century Reformation in Europe, when the Anabaptist movement spurred the creation of three "plain" communities: the Amish, Mennonites and Brethren. Members of this conservative Christian faith came to Pennsylvania in the early 18th century to escape persecution in Europe for their Anabaptist beliefs. Although these spiritual groups have similarities, the Amish are the most conservative, emphasizing humility, family, community and separation from the non-Amish world, which includes a reluctance to adopt modern conveniences such as electricity. But the interesting thing is although the Pennsylvania Amish resist cultural influences, they are willing to strike compromises with the modern world, tapping its benefits while still preserving the Amish identity. They are willing to use modern technology to work and communicate - as long as they do not disrupt family and community stability.
Our first stop in Amish’s landscape was at Daniel’s house. Daniel is twelve years old and he is a smart and talkative boy. He has a very unique accent. I had hard times to understand what he said while explaining the Amish’s lives, what they do and how they live. Amish children had formal education only lasts through the eighth grade. There is no option to attend modern public school, nor a higher education institution. The Amish in Lancaster, PA believe that either of these options would pull children away from their community's families and church traditions, threatening their values with individualism, competition, rational thinking and secularism.
After showing us his family workhouse, we had this chance to look around of their mare installation. The mares are very lovely. We took a lot of pictures there. But one important thing that must be remembered when visiting Amish Country is “do not take picture of their faces”. You still can take picture of their horses, houses, farms, buggies, but better asking for permission first. Just as the Amish do not carry personal photographs or display them in homes, they do not want others to take photographs of them. The Amish believe that photographs in which they can be recognized violate the Biblical commandment, "Thou shalt not make unto thyself a graven image." They want to be remembered by the lives they lived and the examples they left, not by physical appearance.
Once I asked Mom Debra what happened if we insist to take pictures of their faces, are they going to be angry? Or how would they react? Mom Debra said that she, once, made this mistake taking picture of them and they didn’t say anything, “But you can see the pain on their faces and you definitely don’t want to see that”, said Mom Debra. Jane, our guide, told that when we take pictures of them, they believe that their soul is taken away.
Amish community lives in a very peaceful life. They never fight back when they are hurt. They are very forgiving. In the middle of the tour when we passed by Amish school, Jane told us this story about five Amish children who murdered while they are in school. The murderer had mental disorder. The family of the murderer came to the community and asking for forgiveness and they said that they already forgave and would never mention about that again. The even did not sue the murderer. I cannot imagine how if that’s happened to my family. Probably I would never forgive the murderer and definitely would sue him. That day, I learnt about forgiving.
Our adventure in Amish country is ended by dinner in Ebersol’s house. They served a very very very good food. I love the peanut butter a lot. That was the best meal I have ever had in my life. They also sang for us. I felt peaceful there. I wish someday I could return to the Lancaster County with my children and taught them about norm and values that I learnt from the Amish.
--Cut Nury Hikmah Sabry, University of Indonesia
Boy
is it nice to be back in America. I have a new appreciation for
plugging things directly into the wall. In fact, I can charge my laptop,
iPhone, and digital camera all at the same time. I can't even describe
how something so simple has brought me such immense joy. The stark
contrast between living like that and visiting the Amish has only helped
me to appreciate it more. The Amish live in a way that preserves their
religion and culture, while at the same time is fulfilling to them as
people, however, I think that sacrificing electricity and other modern
amenities for the sake of being "plain" is unfair. I think it would
benefit them to modernize minimally. They probably don't know what they
are missing since they don't live with electricity but they can benefit
from something like this. What if
someone gets into a farming accident, or falls down the stairs?
Traveling via horse and buggy is not the most ideal means of
transportation to a hospital, etc. and calling an ambulance would take
longer than just driving straight there. Things like owning a car or
having a cell phone for emergencies are not necessarily lifestyle
changes, they are precautionary measures that can be taken to ensure the
health and safety of the Amish people. Living in Amish style homes that
are neighboring "English" style homes was one way they are actually
able to get help if an accident or fire were to occur in the
neighborhood. I think that is a smart move for those who have branched
out to live among the Amish/"English" border.
We actually began our day by visiting the Islamic Center of the Muslim Association of the Lehigh Valley, where we spoke to Rizwan Butt, who was an active member of the Muslim community and the committee at the mosque. He was a really endearing person and it was clear that he was so so happy about life and about being Muslim. What I have observed in my parish is quite different than his attitude. Members go to the sermons because they feel obligated to out of guilt or fear that they are sinning rather than going because they actually want to be there. One of the beautiful things about Islam that I really find fascinating is the notion that if you don't participate in your prayers or sermon wholeheartedly, it doesn't count. It makes me respect them even more because I know that they are (especially in America) following something that is a passion for them and not just something inherited from generations of followers. We had even met a young family that had converted to Islam from Catholicism. I really enjoyed that portion of our day and I really hope that the participants get to do it again next year. Can't wait to shop tomorrow!! $$$$$
--Shannon Cassidy, Lehigh University
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)